The first sign of rebellion often comes with concerns that leave a single detractor uneasy, particularly when committed to events or ideals that’d be the farthest from a safe reality. Denounce the possible loss of life, degradation of morals, or excess of outlandish style, and a player in the demonstrative Hunger Games has won half the battle. In this second prequel installment, Sunrise on the Reaping, director Francis Lawrence is once more out to claim, at minimum, a 150% victory with Suzanne Collins’ novels, and Billy Ray returning at long last to craft an expertly visceral shooting script that hardly falls flat at any point of sacrifice. Aware that Songbirds and Snakes was meant to be no more than a tonal warm-up, Lawrence considers full re-entry into that glorified fight choreography, moral implication, and conscientious character building like it hadn’t really gone away.
If anything, there’s some lost time now made up through Collins’ electiveness to play the prequel card. 24 years before the events of the original 2012 film, the Games are an elaborate anchor to Panem’s dystopian social order. Only the actions of a sole observer could be crafty enough to disrupt them. 20-something Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada) is the type to live with unending empathy, sharing the best of life with secret girlfriend Lenore (Whitney Peak).

Maintaining that cover while living in District 12 is a completely different story, however. Nothing can prevent the lottery-like selection, and Haymitch is the least qualified of any fighter in the hotly contested Second Quarter Quell. Think of it as a massive November sweeps ratings stunt, if it were modeled after Battle Royale, Edgar Wright’s take on The Running Man, or Lawrence’s recent take on The Long Walk. It is a traditional installment of the Games, all told, the capitol’s battleground treated like a pastoral haven, which Jo Willems shoots with heavy-fisted splendor, while paired with mid-1970s interior architecture (credited with flair to Uli Hanisch and Thorsten Klein).
And yet, the extra bells and whistles give it the randomest spin-off feel. And that is a clear idea Haymitch needn’t get swept up by. His mission, upon entering the bracket, not just to survive and win, but to send a message to President Snow (Ralph Fiennes with full forked tongue) that this heightened bloodsport can’t last forever. Nor can the Capitol as it stands now, let alone its overall leader Drusilla (Glenn Close, with the best prosthetics use of her later career); there is a plan in motion, with noble scientist Beetee (Kelvin Harrison, Jr.) ready to recruit in its execution.
Rightful, skillful vengeance is the greatest weapon against reality television’s manipulation of the truth. As a fringe fan of this series, even I can say, for all the impressive fight choreo and adversity to navigate between characters (Haymitch is a titan of resilience, in that regard), that collective effort to challenge the media and dismantle their reframing of narratives has been sorely missed. Ray’s unflinchingness to elevate Collins’ manner of depth and provocation makes the largest of differences, like we forgot that had always been available. It couldn’t be any more essential to show, in full transparency, the horror of pacification, and those low-key, no less controversial ways to push back.

And the most notable part of that idea being approached again in Lawrence’s field of vision has to be how equally unflinching and lavish the conflict is, with the ensemble, set pieces and obscenely threatening wildlife, to match. No one may forget the docile flock of electricity-conducting butterflies or a random active volcano in the background, though the hazard of forgetting some smaller details might be imminent for some. Mark Yoshikawa, the franchise’s resident editor since Mockingjay, still can’t avoid constructing a heavy kitchen sink without the chance to parse it down. Just like Songbirds, it’s never incredibly tedious, but the runtime still groans to utter overwhelm. It’s far too much material at times, though it all still serves a necessary purpose, so it’d be difficult to itemize anything worthy of removal. Especially with how effectively the director’s forward-thinking zeal aligns with his cast, never quite missing an emotional beat, consequential line of dialogue, or bombastic combat gesture.
Sunrise could easily be one of the better-recruited films this year as far as a rounded ensemble. Fiennes and Close land in admirable villain territory. Only to be then cautiously outshadowed by the presence of TV ringleader Caesar Flickerman (Kieran Culkin, embracing the deep cut character lifestyle better than what Johnny Depp’s come back to), Effie the stylist (a persistently scene-stealing Elle Fanning), and valiant dissident Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons, a shameless dead ringer for Phillip Seymour Hoffman, down to suave demeanor). And Zada, the true up-and-comer, knows how to combine all three and make them seem unified without an ounce of hesitation. His compassion and fury never shy from responding to a given moment as accurately as one in his position can, instilling an advantageous mindset upon his D12 competitors (or would they be more frenemies?) – Maysilee (McKenna Grace), Wyatt (Ben Wang), and Louella (Molly McCann), all of whom add personal integrity and grief for that increasing defensiveness.

Cut a certain chunk of clutter, and that fight-or-flight response would’ve rubbed off on the audience with added asperity. But it still had to’ve felt longer on the written page, the film adaptation still knowing, somewhat, how to compartmentalize and revive the art of anarchy which the previous trilogy held constant, while uncovering the Capitol’s deepest mysteries. The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is Collins’ way of exposing them as a significant threat whose echoes still ring out in the distance, heard by those most haunted, and most determined to enact a thoughtful rehab of personal freedom. Despite being a lengthy slog overvaluing its sense of conflict, Lawrence still does what is necessary to remind even long-standing fans of past glory and future opportunity, while the next generation of actors prepares their own revolution against an already disturbed reality (that has to sound familiar to someone). And for that measure, it is a win worthy of the big screen, and preferably with a clear mind ready to support a catalyst for change. (7/10)